Anthony Alford September Callup

The Likely Blue Jays September Roster Additions

With the Blue Jays battling nicks, bumps, outright injuries, and the general fatigue that come with the slog that is the MLB season, the team’s impending September reinforcements will be a welcome sight. They could use help in a variety of spots regardless of whether they’re trying to climb atop Trash Mountain in the chase for the second wild card or looking to get their important players some extra rest ahead of a long offseason.

For reference, here are the team’s September call-ups from the past three seasons:

2014: Daniel Norris, Dalton Pompey, Kendall Graveman, Anthony Gose, Ryan Goins, Sean Nolin, Brandon Morrow, Dan Johnson, George Kottaras

At the end of the month the team recalled Rob Rasmussen, Steve Delabar, A.J. Jimenez, Colt Hynes and Kyle Drabek.

2015: Aaron Loup, Jeff Francis, Ryan Tepera, Dalton Pompey, Munenori Kawasaki, Josh Thole

That season, the team would later add Steve Delabar, Matt Hague and a returning Marcus Stroman to the mix.

2016: Ryan Tepera, Danny Barnes, Matt Dermody, Dalton Pompey, Darrell Ceciliani

Aaron Loup, Bo Schultz, Chris Smith and Andy Burns were recalled later in the month.

Looking at past tendencies, we’d guess that the team is going to call on a third catcher, an outfielder or two, a handful of pitchers and one infielder for both the middle and corner spots.

There’s plenty of intriguing options up and down the organizational depth chart and the team could go in a number of directions with the final month of the season. While that will largely be determined by the optics of the playoff chase, we’ll try and identify some of the best call-up targets.


Good Chance: Anthony Alford, Dwight Smith Jr., Teoscar Hernandez

If things really go sour in the next week or two, the Jays would have a great opportunity to look at some of their younger outfield prospects. Steve Pearce shouldn’t be patrolling left every day and Jose Bautista probably shouldn’t have been put in right to begin with. Once the season meets its inevitable end, there’s also little sense in risking Kevin Pillar’s health in meaningless games. Bring on the youth.

We’ve already seen two of the above trio in Alford and Smith, and the former has recovered quite nicely from late-May surgery on his left wrist. Through Monday, Alford owned a 13-game hitting streak for AA New Hampshire and boasts a season-long slash line of .322/.418/.455 in 59 games at that level.

Smith has gotten a few short stints with the big club this season and was sent down to Buffalo when Ezequiel Carrera returned from the DL at the end of June. In 97 games with the Bisons, DSJ has been good for a .276/.349/.404 line.

The 24-year-old Hernandez was the key piece in the Francisco Liriano deal, though he has struggled a bit since joining Buffalo. He is hitting just .175 in 17 games as a member of the Blue Jays organization but had a much more palatable .261/.369/.485 slash line in Fresno, collecting 12 homers and 12 steals for his troubles.

The trio are also helped out by the fact that they are currently on the 40-Man Roster, meaning that their call-ups wouldn’t necessitate a secondary move to remove someone else from the 40-Man once rosters expand. We’re very likely to see at least two, if not all three of these outfielders in September.

Maybes: Michael Saunders

Old friend alert. The Jays let Saunders walk following a second half collapse last season and he was forced to sign a relatively cheap deal with the Phillies. That obviously didn’t work out, so he signed a minor league pact with Toronto upon his release from Philadelphia. With just two homers and a line of .267/.318/.392 in 29 games with the Bisons, it’s hard to argue that he’s really earned a promotion on merit. He does have MLB pedigree, however, and though he’s not on the 40-Man it’s not crazy to think that he could make an appearance.

Longshots: Dalton Pompey

Pompey was supposed to be a legitimate contender for an outfield spot out of spring training only for ill-timed injuries to crush any hopes of a full year with the big club. A concussion and some knee problems derailed his year and he has only played 13 games to this point. If he can somehow prove himself healthy he’d be the top choice, but there’s almost zero chance that the team rushes him back from a lost season.


Good Chance: Luke Maile

Sunday’s woeful performance from Raffy Lopez probably drew a disproportionate amount of ire, but he’s likely on the outs as soon as Toronto’s veterans return. If Luke Maile recovers from his right knee irritation soon (and the expectation is that he will), expect he and Miguel Montero to form the one-two punch at catcher. If and when Russell Martin returns, Maile will revert to a third catcher role.

Maybes: Devon Travis, Mike Ohlman

The team would love to have Travis back to man second base and he seems on track to return before the season is up, but whether or not they push it will depend on how much ground they can make up on the teams ahead of them.

Back to catcher now, as Ohlman would probably be the call if Maile doesn’t get healthy and the Jays tire of Lopez. Filling the third (or fourth) catcher role, he’d get minimal playing time anyway.

Longshots: Jason Leblebijian, Rowdy Tellez, Richard Urena, Lourdes Gurriel

If the team can’t get Travis back in time and feels the need for more infield depth, they could call up Jason Leblebijian in his stead. He was the new hotness back in the early going but faded as the season wore on and is currently sporting 11 homers, 58 RBI and a .244/.314./.394 line through 108 games. Leblebijian is not on the 40-Man but it’s not like he’d need to take the place of a super valuable player if push came to shove.

Alternatively, they could call on a middle-infielder currently on the roster in Richard Urena. It doesn’t make a ton of sense to rush him given that the Jays already have three middle infield types on the roster (and seem intent on playing Josh Donaldson more at short now), but stranger things have happened. He’s posted a .285 OBP with New Hampshire so it’d be a real surprise to see him get the call. Versatile 23-year-old Lourdes Gurriel would be a shade more deserving but the Jays don’t seem likely to rush him to the majors.

Tellez was shaping up as the heir apparent at first base coming into the season but has really struggled with Buffalo, delivering just six home runs while hitting .219/.286/.333 in his first season at AAA. It’d take an injury or two for Tellez to get a sniff at this point.


Good Chance: Joe Biagini, Tom Koehler, Tim Mayza, Mike Bolsinger, Leonel Campos, Chris Smith

These are all familiar faces with the exception of Koehler, who the team just went out and acquired. Biagini could take up a rotation spot if need be while the rest would work in relief. Bolsinger would need to be re-added to the 40 Man in order to come up (as would Smith) but at least provides a known quantity.

Maybes: Brett Anderson, Jeff Beliveau, Ryan Borucki

Of this group, oft-injured Brett Anderson has the best chance to appear with the Jays. The team signed him to a low-risk contract that expires at the end of this season, so if he’s healthy it’s probably worth using him at the MLB level to see if there’s anything there for next season.

Beliveau could come up if the team wants another lefty specialist, as he had actually fared pretty well with the Jays earlier in the year. His 7.47 ERA is very misleading as the southpaw was working with an ERA in the mid-threes before getting blitzed for six runs without recording an out against Cleveland.

Borucki has turned a strong season across two levels of the minor league system and could be valuable depth as either a spot starter or a bullpen guy. In 98 innings with Dunedin he delivered a 3.58 ERA with 109 strikeouts and 29 walks and then has been even better since his call up to New Hampshire. In 39.1 innings in Double-A he has pitched to a 2.29 ERA with 35 strikeouts and eight walks . Borucki is also on the 40-Man so there’d be no corresponding move to make if the Jays wanted to test him down the stretch.

Longshots: Conner Greene, Sean Reid-Foley

Though both are some of the team’s more well regarded prospects, neither is on the roster at the moment and they’ve had their share of struggles in the minors. The odds are long, but it’s not as though the team hasn’t called up name brand pitching prospects before.

Picking right now, Dwight Smith Jr., Hernandez, Biagini, Koehler, Mayza, Chris Smith, and Campos seem like the most likely wave of call-ups with the admission that there’s plenty of variables in the stack of pitchers. Luke Maile and Devon Travis will probably join the Jays off the DL. Rob Refsnyder sort of serves as the late-season middle infield depth already, and the potential return of Travis means there’s no urgency to add depth there. It’s a similar story on the corners, where a few current options could play third while Steve Pearce can pick up innings at first base if he’s really needed.

That’s a preliminary guess, and there will almost surely be some events over the next week and a half that change the team’s needs and priorities. The list of players above is also far from gospel, as it was only last year that Matt Dermody got the call out of nowhere. As the season winds down, Toronto can use these extra roster spots to either give John Gibbons more weapons in his uphill battle or get their prospects some valuable big league exposure. There are plenty of options down either path.

Lead Photo © Kim Klement-USA TODAY Sports

Related Articles

11 comments on “The Likely Blue Jays September Roster Additions”


I am sorry but I have to rate this article as completely lacking in insight or knowledge of the Jays system. Maile would not be a call up as he is already on roster and et to return. Jansen would be a likely call up.

The most obvious call up of all at any position is Carlos Ramirez and he isn’t even mentioned. Shame.

This article never should have seen the light of day.


I have to agree with JP, and add the following: why would we bring up Hernandez who is batting .170 at AAA and leave Roemon Fields who is batting .300, who has great speed, and who is a better CF than Teoscar.

Matt Gwin

Hate to break up the party here guys, but even if the Blue Jays were to call up the two players you mentioned (they won’t), it won’t matter. They’re a couple of 26 year old non-prospects.

Please direct your complaints to my complaints department:

K Shaw

Why is Carlos Ramirez a non-prospect? He may be 26 years old, but he’s a converted outfielder with all of 148.2 IP over 4 seasons as a professional, with a 2.48 career ERA and all of 6 home runs allowed.

Chronological age has little relevance for prospect evaluation beyond physical and emotional maturation. What matters is baseball age. Chris Rowley and Carlos Ramirez might be chronologically old for their levels, but they’re still young as professional pitchers. From the other side, we (rightfully) slobber all over Vlad Guerrero and the way he’s crushing A-ball as an 18-year old. But let’s not forget that this is probably the appropriate level for his development age. That dude has done nothing in life except hit baseballs since he was 13 years old.


They won’t call up Carlos Ramirez? How did that work out?

K Shaw

SRF is beyond long-shot. His call-up probability is precisely 0%.

Tellez’s chances are barely any better. Given the way he has struggled against AAA pitching, it seems almost a foregone conclusion that he won’t be Rule 5 protected this offseason.


Lol. Tellez not being Rule 5 protected. Lol.

You kind of undermine the validity of any of your comments but stating that Tellez will be left unprotected this offseason.


I mean, yeah most of those suggestions were terrible, but Carlos Ramirez 100% should be on there … whatever you might think of his prospect status, he’s putting up ridiculous numbers and will more than likely get a look. He’s not a guaranteed call-up, but barring a significant regression he’ll be picked up before Borucki, Green, or Reid-Foley.

Joshua Howsam

Say what you guys want about Ramirez, he’s still not on the 40-man, so the team may prefer guys with big league experience for those spots over him. They may want a look since he’d need to go on the 40-man in the offseason, but at the same time if the club felt he were such a lock to help, he’d likely be up over guys like Mayza and especially Dermody already. That’s not to say he WON’T be called up, but he’s very far away from a sure thing. Greene and SRF are considered (and again, long shots and listed as such) because they’re big armed prospects whose ability and performance could play up in the bullpen. Similar applies to long shot Tellez. He’s a guy the club was high on and they may want a look, but it’s not close to the likely side (which is why the author said it would take injuries for him to get a chance).

As for Fields over Hernandez, one of those players is on the 40-man roster and likely seriously in the mix for either a starting or backup outfield spot next year. The other is Roemon Fields. Their current stats in AAA are not close to the only thing the team will value when deciding on callups.

And finally (to the first commenter), the Maile comment is just ridiculously pedantic. You may notice that the piece is titled “roster additions.” This piece is about players that could be on the team in September with added rosters that aren’t now. Players on the DL (especially those with options like Maile) needed to be listed.

K Shaw

There are too many candidates for Rule 5 protection this offseason for someone like SRF to get any consideration.

Joshua Howsam

That’s certainly fair and a very worthy point. A guy like him would only even be thought of as possible if the Jays vaulted back into serious postseason contention and they thought he could be a real weapon down the stretch. That’s also why it’s not 0%, though. It may be VERY close to zero, but not an absolute no.

But it’s worth saying, quibbling about the people listed as long shots here kind of misses the entire point of the piece. My guess is that they were mostly mentioned because they’re noteworthy players and the author would almost certainly get questions about them if they were not included. Nobody (including the author) thinks they’re coming up, hence the long shot dept.

Leave a comment

Use your Baseball Prospectus username